Skip to content

November 5, 2026 · EZ Home Buyers Team

What Cash Home Buyers Actually Pay in Brooklyn, With the Math Shown

Brooklyn sellers ask us one question before any other: what will you actually pay? Most cash buyer websites answer with a slogan. We would rather show the arithmetic, because once you can see how the number is built you can check any offer you get, ours included, and know whether it is fair.

This is the Brooklyn version of the Queens breakdown we published earlier. The formula is the same. The inputs are different, because Brooklyn houses are older, more of them are two and three families, and the gap between a block in Park Slope and a block in East New York is wider than anything in Queens.

The formula, in one line

Every legitimate cash buyer in Brooklyn works backward from the same place: what the house will sell for once it is fixed. Take that number, subtract the cost of the work, subtract the cost of carrying and reselling it, subtract a margin, and what is left is the offer. Four numbers. A buyer who will not show you all four is hiding one.

Here is a worked example on a typical call we get: a 1920s brick two family in East Flatbush, original kitchens, a boiler from the 1980s, a finished cellar with a tenant, and an estate behind it.

Step one: the fixed up value

Renovated two families on the same blocks have been closing between $1,050,000 and $1,150,000 this year. We use the lower end, not the record, because the record was a corner lot with a driveway and this house has neither. Call it $1,075,000.

This is the number most sellers never see, and it is the one worth arguing about. If a buyer starts from $950,000 when the comps say $1,075,000, every other step is built on a false floor. Ask for the comparable sales by address. We give them to you on the offer sheet.

Step two: the work

Two kitchens, two bathrooms, a boiler, electrical service, a roof with layers on it, and restoring the cellar to a cellar because the apartment down there will never be legal. In Brooklyn in 2026 that job, done to a standard a financed buyer’s inspector will pass, runs $165,000. Add a contingency for what the walls hide in a hundred year old house, because they always hide something. Total work: $185,000.

Sellers routinely guess half that. Contractors who are not bidding to actually do the work will tell you half that. The number that matters is the one someone will sign a contract for.

Step three: carrying and selling

Between the day we close and the day the renovated house closes to its next owner, we pay property taxes, insurance, utilities, and in most cases a lender. In Brooklyn, with Department of Buildings permits and a Housing Court case for the cellar tenant, that is eight to ten months. Then there is the resale itself: New York State and City transfer taxes, a broker, attorney fees, and the buyer’s lender taking its time. Carrying and selling on this house: $95,000.

This is the number sellers underestimate most, because they never carry an empty house with a mortgage on it. We do, on every house.

Step four: the margin

We are a business. On a project with this much risk, the margin is around 12 percent of the fixed up value, which here is $130,000. If the renovation runs over, the market dips, or the cellar case takes a year, that margin is what absorbs it. A buyer promising a tiny margin on a gut renovation is either lying about the margin or about the work.

The offer

$1,075,000 minus $185,000 minus $95,000 minus $130,000 equals $665,000. That is the offer on this house, written out on one page with the comparable sales listed by address, before the walkthrough changes anything.

Now compare that with listing. A buyer with a mortgage would pay more on paper, say $750,000, and then the inspector writes four pages, the appraiser does not count the cellar, the lender wants the apartment removed before closing, the deal dies in week four, and the second buyer asks for a credit. After commission, the credit, six more months of taxes and the estate attorney’s extra hours, sellers in this exact situation have netted less than the cash number. Not always. Often enough that we show the comparison on the offer sheet.

What raises an offer in Brooklyn

  • Land a builder wants. A tired house on a wide lot near a subway in Flatbush or Bed Stuy can be worth more to a developer than to a family. We price the house both ways and show you both.
  • A legal two or three family. If the certificate of occupancy matches what is on site, the fixed up value is based on real rents and goes up. If it does not, see below.
  • Structurally sound, visually dated. Original kitchens scare financed buyers and cost far less than people think. A solid brick house with a 1975 interior is one of the best things we can buy.
  • Clean title and a clear timeline. If the estate letters are in hand or the lender’s payoff letter is current, our risk drops and the offer rises.

What lowers an offer

  • The cellar apartment. It is almost never legal and no lender counts it. We price the house as its legal units. We wrote a full guide on selling a house with an illegal basement apartment.
  • A tenant who is not paying. Brooklyn Housing Court takes most of a year. The case transfers to us at closing, but the months come out of the offer. Our guide to selling with tenants in place covers how we price it.
  • Open violations and liens. Department of Buildings, Environmental Control Board, water and sewer balances. They get paid at closing out of the price, itemized. They do not stop the sale.
  • A block the comps do not support. A house in Canarsie is not priced off Park Slope sales, and the reverse. We use sales within a few blocks, and we show them.

How to check any offer you get

  1. Ask for the fixed up value and the three comparable sales behind it, by address. If the buyer cannot name them, the number is made up.
  2. Ask for the renovation estimate as a list, not a lump sum.
  3. Ask what the carrying and resale costs are. A buyer who says zero has never carried a house.
  4. Ask for the margin. Twelve to fifteen percent on a gut job is normal. Five percent is a story.
  5. Add it up yourself. If the four numbers do not produce the offer, something is missing.

Current typical values for every Brooklyn neighborhood we buy in are on our New York home prices page, updated monthly.

This is general information about how cash offers are built, not an offer on any specific property. Every house is priced after a walkthrough. Numbers in the example are rounded and reflect 2026 Brooklyn conditions.

If you own a house anywhere in Brooklyn and want our number on it with the math shown, call (516) 964-7222 or send the address through the form below. The offer comes back in writing within 24 hours, no obligation.

Get your cash offer

Want the math on your own house? Send the address and get a written number with every line shown.

Free, no obligation

Get your cash offer

Takes 60 seconds. We respond within 24 hours.

(516) 964-7222 Get cash offer →